Breaking Down Starvation Mode: Why Extreme Calorie Restriction Doesn’t Work

The diet world is full of quick weight loss hacks, and every evolving fad is all too often disguised as wellness. The concept of restricting calories to the point of starvation is one of the greatest lies that has ever been sold, so much so that it has impacted multiple generations in Western culture. Working in Outpatient Nutrition counseling, one of the biggest barriers I would have to get my clients through was not starving themselves to lose weight. 

The Concept of Starvation Mode: Your Body’s Protective Response  

When you severely restrict calorie intake, your body responds by conserving all energy. Basically, your body is very good at protecting itself from many things, even you, and the result will probably not make you happy. When you overly restrict caloric intake, also known as energy intake, your metabolism will decrease. So, for all of you who like to skip meals, this is why you are gaining weight. You are not consistently fueling your body; therefore, all consumed energy is stored for later. How does the body store energy? The stored energy can be recognized as body fat, often unwanted.

Another protective measure your body will do is adjust your metabolism (resting energy expenditure and non-resting energy expenditure) based on how much or how little calories you take in. This adjustment in energy expenditure is a process called adaptive thermogenesis (AT). AT can make it challenging to maintain weight loss as the body does not recognize this as the goal; this is why some may regain lost weight. Remember, your body is used to being at the weight you have been at, and any acute change will trigger a survival response. This is not a reason to continue being overly restrictive, though!

Your Body’s Response to Caloric Restriction: More Than Just Slowing Down

Perhaps we should take a few steps back and define metabolism. Metabolism is the total sum of chemical reactions that occur in your cells to convert the food you eat into energy. The energy that is created fuels vital functions like breathing, blood circulation, movement (voluntary and involuntary), body temperature regulation, and so on. While calorie intake plays a big role in your metabolism, it is only part of the picture when looking at weight management. Other factors that influence your metabolism, from a weight management perspective, are age, hormones, and muscle mass-to-fat ratio. 

Having a higher lean body mass or muscle mass ratio than fat mass aides in weight management, as it takes more energy to maintain and fuel lean body mass. As we age, we lose lean body mass, so it is important to incorporate strength and resistance exercises into your routine to preserve muscle and strengthen bone density. The best thing to do is establish a good exercise routine and maintain this throughout the aging process. 

Hormones are another factor that can regulate body weight. There are several of them, but I will focus on two for this guide—specifically, the two hormones that regulate appetite and weight control: ghrelin and leptin. Ghrelin, more commonly referred to as the hunger hormone, is produced primarily in your stomach and signals to your brain that you are hungry. This is a basic survival hormone, as when calories are restricted, the levels of this hormone increase, telling you it’s time to eat. The more restrictive you are, the stronger your feelings of hunger will be.

Leptin, on the other hand, regulates your body weight by signaling when you are full. The less body fat, the higher the leptin level, and conversely, the more body fat a person has, the lower the leptin. The exception is leptin resistance, meaning there is no cue to feel satiated (or full) when someone is leptin resistant. Because of this, a person may continue taking in calories or use excessive energy beyond what is needed. Inconsistent “dieting” methods, including restrictive eating, can impact hormones by reducing the ability of these chemicals to function as they are properly intended.

Sustainable Weight Loss Strategies: Beyond the Crash Diet

One of the best ways to manage your weight is to adopt healthy lifestyle practices. While some of these fad diets may have been created with the best intentions, they do not work if there is no education on what to do after the specified time you are to follow them. Diets that have time limits of 30-90 days are not sustainable if they are over-restrictive and impact your life negatively. Instead, learning how food intake works by eating balanced and nutrient-dense foods at the right time can get you on the path to long-term changes in your health. 

Implementing the following tips into your lifestyle will allow you to meet realistic and sustainable goals:

1. Meal Timing – Eating within one-two hours of waking and then eating every three to five hours after that and stopping eating one-two hours before laying down for bed allows for appropriate timing of nutrients and hormone regulation. The following chart is one of many examples of how to time your meals:

2. Balanced Eating—Protein is a great nutrient to include whenever you eat, as it takes longer to digest. Therefore, it promotes a controlled rise and decline in blood sugar. Often, there is an overabundance of carbohydrate consumed and not nearly enough protein. When eating carbohydrates alone, your blood sugar spikes, causing a flood of insulin to be released, followed by a “crash.” Also, excess carbohydrate intake that is not needed for replenishing glycogen stores (found in the brain and muscle) is converted to stored body fat, which is part of the body's survival mechanism. This is why balancing meals by including a protein source with each meal or snack is important. 

3. Physical Activity—We were made to move! A stagnant and sedentary lifestyle will wreak havoc on your body. Incorporating strength and cardiovascular training will help build lean muscle and increase metabolic activity. Exercise will also reduce chronic illnesses that can impact organs and other important, large systems of the body. 

4. Hydration— Maintaining appropriate hydration levels can also help you with weight management. Sustaining your hydration levels is key all the way to a cellular level. This controls the levels of a hormone called angiotensin II, which is often associated with chronic disease. However, you want to be mindful not to consume large volumes of fluids directly at mealtimes, as this can push food through digestion too quickly. When this happens, you can cause dumping syndrome, decreased nutrient absorption, and potential blood sugar spikes. Instead, allow a 30-minute break from fluids before and after eating; sips during are okay, just not in large quantities.

5. Quality Food Choices— Choosing nutrient-dense food options is your best bet regarding your dietary pattern. As stated earlier, you want to have a balance of carbohydrates and protein, but that’s only half your plate. Including vegetables and healthy fats will round out your nutrients and ensure you get everything you need from the foods you eat. Limit or eliminate highly processed foods when possible and choose lean protein sources, carbohydrates that contain fiber, and varied colors of vegetables. 

6. Healthy Sleep Habits— Sleep is when your body conducts many activities at a metabolic level, including recovery and repair. Having poor quality sleep habits can be detrimental to your health and well-being. Whether it is poor quality from too much screen time, deprivation from overextending yourself, or a poor sleeping environment, you want to correct this. Small things like turning off all screens 30 min before sleep, not having a TV in your room, making sure you are getting 7-8 hours per night, and even having the right pillow or mattress can make a huge difference. If you feel like you have sleep apnea, then scheduling a sleep study and determining if you need a C-PAP may also be a helpful thing to look into. 

When to Seek Professional Help: Addressing Weight Loss Challenges 

Meeting with your healthcare team can be an important step if you are experiencing and unplanned challenges. If you are having significant, unplanned weight loss or gain, then you may have underlying health concerns. Your doctor can run tests, check your labs, and refer you to a dietitian. This team effort can help diagnose the issue and get you on a more individualized plan for your specific needs. A dietitian understands acute and chronic conditions and how to adapt to your eating habits to support your health better. 

Lastly, if you feel like you're spinning your wheels on your own, a registered dietitian can help you get moving in the right direction. You can get personalized guidance from someone who can keep you accountable and cheer you on throughout your journey to lifestyle changes. One thing to remember, there are no quick fixes. Habits and behaviors take time to develop and will also take time to change. Be patient and give yourself grace through the journey. If you have any comments or advice to share, please feel free to add a comment below!

1. _{Ghrelin hormone: Function and definition. Cleveland Clinic. (2024, May 1). https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/body/22804-ghrelin} 
2. _{Heinitz, S., Hollstein, T., Ando, T., Walter, M., Basolo, A., Krakoff, J., Votruba, S. B., & Piaggi, P. (2020). Early adaptive thermogenesis is a determinant of weight loss after six weeks of caloric restriction in overweight subjects. Metabolism: clinical and experimental, 110, 154303. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.metabol.2020.154303}  
3. _{Leptin: What it is, Function & Levels. Cleveland Clinic. (2024g, May 1). https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/articles/22446-leptin} 
4. _{Thornton S. N. (2016). Increased Hydration Can Be Associated with Weight Loss. Frontiers in nutrition, 3, 18. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2016.00018} 
5. _{Thyfault, J. P., & Bergouignan, A. (2020). Exercise and metabolic health: beyond skeletal muscle. Diabetologia, 63(8), 1464–1474. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00125-020-05177-6} 
6. _{What is metabolism?. Cleveland Clinic. (2024, November 21). https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/body/21893-metabolism}